Tuesday, 10 May 2011

Verbatim report: MPs clash over Besigye video

This week, MPs spent four days debating the inhumane manner in which plain-clothed security operatives arrested opposition leader, Dr Kizza Besigye.
However, hell broke loose when opposition MPs rejected a purported video footage of that day’s events produced by government, saying it was doctored. This resulted in more videos (from government and opposition) being presented to show the ugly scenes during Besigye’s arrest.
David Tash Lumu & Sulaiman Kakaire captured the debate as it threatened to boil over.

Edward Ssekandi (Speaker): Honourable members, I see that you have expressed a high spirit of patriotism today (referring to the high attendance). Please continue with the same spirit.

Matia Kasaija (State minister for Internal Affairs): I found it important to show the House the video recording of what happened during the arrest of Dr Kizza Besigye. I also want to answer the wild accusations that were made by some members on Thursday (April 28) last week when Dr Besigye was arrested.
And this statement answers the questions that this House raised on that day. (Kasaija presents statement and also shows MPs the official government video footage of the events that led to the arrest of Besigye and how he was evacuated from his car by Gilbert Bwana Arinaitwe and Police).

Alice Alaso (Soroti Woman):
We think that there were missed facts in what the minister presented to the House. This statement should clarify the source of the hammer and the way in which the commando (man wearing a hood) hit the left side of the car. So, who were these commandos behind the arrest of Dr Besigye?

Hussein Kyanjo (Makindye West):
We have landed into a problem of watching videos that are disconnected, but I would like to appeal to the minister to be extra sensitive about the lives of the Ugandans who are perishing in these riots. Even if Besigye misbehaved, the issue is; how was he handled when he misbehaved?
And I think there is a problem of plain-clothed police officers arresting suspects. From the video clip that was shown, there was involvement of officers in plain clothes arresting people. Who are they? And if they are security officers, I think what is taking place is not right, you can’t use such officers to arrest suspects.

John Nasasira (Kazo; minister of Works and Transport): Before elections, Dr Besigye said he would not go to court. So, for those who understand, this would not mean a walk-to-work campaign. It is more than that. This action for change is not just for change of [commodity and fuel] prices, but a real threat to the country.

Amama Mbabazi (Kinkizi West; minister for Security): First of all, I would like to talk about the question of the law. What does the law say about demonstrations? (Reads Article 70). And this can be read in accordance with Article 43.
So, when you are demonstrating, you should make sure you are not violating the rights of others. Article 212 also says that this will be handled by the police as clearly stipulated in the law. But here, we have video footage of Besigye being directed by the police and he defies the orders.

Mariam Nalubega (Youth Central): I stand with a concern; if you go to Mulago hospital, you will hardly find any victim beyond 30 years. This explains that politicians are using the young people, since they are unemployed. But I request that whoever wants to demonstrate should mobilize their children. Let us be civil and have concern for the young people.

Janet Museveni (Ruhaama; state minister for Karamoja): It is unfortunate for a leader like Dr Besigye to show the kind of behaviour he has been showing day after day. It is even more unfortunate, for members of the opposition to try to defend his actions.
Mr Besigye did not show any leadership capacity because if he had any [leadership capabilities], he should have accepted police orders. I think the opposition should do what they preach because when they come here, they say a lot but nothing is shown out there.

Beatrice Anywar (Kitgum Woman): Is it in order for the honourable member (Museveni) to say that Dr Besigye has no leadership capacity? That a person who has served in various capacities as a leader and a former physician to the current President of Uganda has no capacity! (Ssekandi laughs).

Bright Rwamirama (Isingiro North): The way we are moving as leaders is unfortunate. Even in our own homes, we express displeasure, but you cannot do it continuously. When we become leaders, we labour so much and cease living ordinary lifestyle.
I was so much hurt about the way Mr Besigye, my long-time friend, got involved in activities that caused suffering to many innocent people. But I also think the picture, which appeared in the Daily Monitor, should be investigated. I do not see a possibility of a hammer hitting a car windscreen three times and it fails to break unless it is a bullet proof car.

Sulaiman Madada (Bbaale): When I watched this video, I [saw] that the political class in Uganda is becoming different. I think we political leaders should be careful, and be responsible for actions that will affect our people.

Lulume Bayiga (Buikwe South): This report (statement) lacks three things. First, it lacks an apology to the citizens of the country. Secondly, the number of those who lost lives. And thirdly, the state of our country’s security.

Achia Remigio (Pian): Honourable members, instead of debating the videos, we should first solve the problems that led to these videos, instead of dwelling on the past.
Christopher Kibanzanga (Busongora South): I think we don’t come here to win arguments, but rather to debate and find solutions to our problems. Let’s forget the argument and find solutions to the problems at hand. You can assassinate Besigye, but the problems will [remain].

Nandala Mafabi (Budadiri West): Uganda belongs to all of us; don’t try to suppress anybody.

Kasiano Wadri (Terego): Let there be civility while arresting individuals. In the video recording that the government side showed, there was civility during the arrest of the mayor of Washington (to justify the widely condemned manner in which plain-clothed security operatives arrested Besigye, the government also showed video clips of how Vincent Gray, the Mayor of Washington, was arrested for protesting against the budget compromise).
I wish government could have done the same during the arrest of Dr Besigye.  (Janet Museveni shouts).

Nandala Mafabi: I thought Hon Museveni was saved, but I am surprised that she comes here to tell lies. You know the problems; why are you shying away from them? Even if you assassinate Besigye, the issues at hand will stick.

Abdu Katuntu (Bugweri): This is mere acting. Everyone knows what happened, but they [government] brought here the cut-and-paste videos. We can’t accept this. We can sit here and debate, but we should understand that at one point in time, what happened to Dr Besigye could happen to your child or grandchildren.

Livingstone Okello Okello (Chua): People are tired of this government. If you see the way the country is being patrolled, you may think that Amin’s government is back.

Odonga Otto (Aruu):
I think the problem we have is about the fear by the government to expose their weaknesses, just like people [feared] to tell their king that he is naked. Hon Janet [Museveni] should stop pretending here that she is saved when she is blaming the victim (Besigye).
dtlumu@observer.ugThis e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
skakaire@observer.ug

No comments: